Westminster “Makes No Sense”

From the © Carbon Brief

It’s rare these days to see British newspapers from across the political spectrum united in agreement on any issue. Beyond their shared disgust at FIFA, that is. Yet this week they produced a chorus of disapproval for the UK government’s deal with the Chinese to help finance the construction of Hinkley C, the UK’s first new nuclear power plant for a generation. The Telegraph said construction could now begin “within weeks”.

Nils Pratley in The Guardian spoke for many fellow commentators when he said the multi-billion pound deal “makes no sense on so many levels”. His colleague Damian Carrington, the Guardian’s head of environment, said the deal “detonates an atomic bomb under the UK government’s already bewildering energy policy”, pointedly noting that the government is now quietly admitting that nuclear, despite years of head-scratching denials, does receive public subsidy. The Observer was withering about the government’s energy policy: “You have to conclude that [it] lacks competence as well as vision.”

In a letter to the Times, 21 scientists and academics argued that “to slash and burn renewable investment for the sake of costly support for new nuclear is, at the very least, unwise”. Nick Butler in the Financial Times cautioned that “much remains to be negotiated, with the UK at a considerable disadvantage because of its all too evident desperation to complete a deal”. He added: “Energy policy cannot be built on optimistic assumptions. Prudence requires a degree of caution and preparation against the worst case — which at Hinkley must be that the EDF/Areva design of the EPR [ European Pressurised Reactor] is unconstructable in its current form.”

Carbon Brief travelled to Finland to look at the country’s own experience of trying to build an EPR – and it offers a cautionary tale for the UK of lengthy delays, infighting and overspending.

Low cost

The Committee on Climate Change (CCC), meanwhile, could not have picked a more poignant week to publish its report on the cost of low-carbon sources of electricity. The BBC said that the CCC, the government’s official advisers on energy and climate change, concluded “low-carbon electricity, not gas, is the cheapest way to keep lights on and meet carbon targets”.

Carbon Brief also took a close look at the report discovering that the CCC “rows back from the stretching 2030 power decarbonisation target it once advocated, citing delays to the deployment of nuclear and carbon capture and storage”. We also examined what the CCC means when it says wind and solar farms will be effectively “subsidy-free” by 2020.

My work background is in operational meteorology and in my career I have been involved in forecasting for everything from bananas to jumbo jets.I joined the Met Office 1974 as an observer at Glasgow Airport. After training as a forecaster, I worked as an Operational aviation forecaster at various defence sites and airports. In 1982, I moved to Glasgow Weather Centre as a forecaster and STV broadcaster till 1988. He then took up a post as Senior Forecaster London Weather Centre, then Senior Forecaster ITV where I qualified as a trainer in presentation techniques for the ITV Association. After being diagnosed with MS, he moved into management and became Head of London Weather Centre in 1997 followed by a period of front-line management for Southern England and Europe covering London and Cardiff Weather Centres and the Met Offices on defence stations from Akrotiri in Cyprus to St Mawgan in Cornwall. He took up the post of Met Office Chief Advisor for Scotland & Northern Ireland in March 2008 and moved to Edinburgh. I retired in September 2014. My one claim to fame is once performed a comedy sketch on TV with Manuel (Andrew Sachs) from Fawlty Towers in support of Comic Relief.

Tagged with: , , , , , , ,
Posted in Climate Change, Comment, Energy, News, Westminster

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Notes from the Overground on WordPress.com
Recent Posts
%d bloggers like this: